Showing posts with label electronic records. Show all posts
Showing posts with label electronic records. Show all posts

Monday, April 7, 2025

AI in Primary Care: A Problem-First Approach

Last week I wrote about my search for a new primary care physician. Based on my medical physical exam experience and my involvement in the development and teaching of a couple of Artificial Intelligence (AI) courses, thoughts automatically went to where they seem to go a lot these days “Why not use AI?” So I did a little research. Bottom line – it still has a ways to go.

In a recent special report in the Annals of Family Medicine titled AI in Primary Care, Start With the Problem, Dr. John Thomas Menchaca argues for a strategic approach to implementing AI in primary care. Rather than pursuing AI for its own sake, physicians and developers must first identify the right problems to solve. Dr Menchaca compares misguided AI implementations to the Segway—a technological marvel that failed because it didn't address real needs. In contrast, electric scooters succeeded by solving the specific "last mile" problem in urban commuting. Similarly, AI must target precise pain points in healthcare.

Primary care's most pressing issue isn't clinical complexity but time management. Studies reveal full-time primary care physicians work over 11 hours daily, with more than half spent on electronic health record (EHR) tasks—a workload directly linked to high burnout rates. This data provides a clear roadmap for effective AI implementation. The most time-consuming EHR tasks include documentation (the largest time sink), chart review, medication management (which could save up to 2 hours daily based on studies with pharmacy technicians), triaging laboratory results, managing refills, responding to patient messages, and order entry.

Current AI documentation tools show mixed results. Many generate rough drafts requiring substantial editing, sometimes taking as much time as writing notes from scratch. This mirrors issues with traditional clinical decision support tools, which often increase rather than decrease workload. The challenge is developing AI that genuinely saves time in clinical settings by integrating seamlessly into workflows, minimizing oversight requirements, empowering team members to resolve issues independently, and measuring impact through time-saving metrics.

Dr Menchaca calls for academic medicine to bridge the gap between clinicians and developers through partnerships at national conferences, research focused on root causes of inefficiency, detailed workflow analyses, and implementation in organizations that truly prioritize clinician well-being. A key concern is that time saved by AI might simply be filled with additional work—more patients or administrative tasks—highlighting that technology alone cannot fix systemic issues in primary care delivery.

AI won't magically solve problems like overwhelming patient panels or overloaded schedules. As Dr Menchaca notes, "AI is just one tool—a means to an end, not the end itself." Meaningful solutions must ultimately lighten clinicians' workloads. By targeting specific, high-impact areas and measuring success through time saved, AI can contribute to a more sustainable future for primary care.

The message for AI innovators is clear: solve real problems, save real time, and keep the clinicians central to your design process. Only then can AI fulfill its potential to transform primary care by making existing systems work more efficiently rather than attempting to reinvent them.

And of course a disclaimer: I’m just a patient, not a doctor. I have done a lot of industry specific development work over the years though. From a development perspective, Dr Menchaca's approach sure makes a lot of sense.

Friday, April 4, 2025

In Search Of A New Primary Care Physician

[Image AI Created]
My 80-year-old primary care doctor is retiring, forcing me to find someone new. A huge shoutout to Dr William Mugg in South Hadley, Massachusetts who got me this far and who always conducted thorough physical exams, checking my throat, ears, heart and body with careful attention.  

I’ve been shopping for a replacement and found a highly rated doctor in his 40s. My first physical with the new guy was surprisingly different. The initial meeting was excellent - he showed genuine interest in connecting and made me feel comfortable and valued. Things changed though when the exam started, he spent most of the time looking at a laptop asking me questions from a list, clicking answers into an electronic health record (EHR) system and ordering lab work, with minimal physical examination. 

 

What has changed?

I recently read an IEEE Spectrum article titled "The Doctor Will See Your Electronic Health Record Now" that perfectly described this shift. The article explains that today's doctors spend up to 6 hours daily on documentation with only 27% of their time actually interacting face-to-face with patients. While I left with comprehensive lab orders, I missed the hands-on approach that made me feel thoroughly examined and cared for by Dr Mugg. Here’s some background on how things have changed.

 

Looking Back

In 2004, President George W. Bush set an ambitious goal for U.S. healthcare providers to transition to EHRs by 2014, with the vision that a person's complete medical information would be available "at the time and place of care, no matter where it originates." This initiative gained significant momentum with the 2009 HITECH Act, which budgeted $49 billion to promote health information technology.

 

Today

Fast forward to today, and the U.S. has spent over $100 billion on healthcare IT. While nearly 80% of physicians and almost all non-federal acute-care hospitals now use EHR systems, the implementation has fallen short of its original vision in several key ways according to the article:

  • Poor Usability: EHR systems rank in the bottom 10% of IT products for usability. Physicians spend between 3.5 and 6 hours daily on documentation, with only 27% of their time spent face-to-face with patients.
  • Clinician Burnout: 71% of physicians feel EHR systems contribute to burnout, with half of U.S. physicians experiencing burnout symptoms.
  • Limited Interoperability: Despite progress, sharing patient data between different systems remains difficult. An average hospital uses 10 different EHR vendors internally, and many specialists have unique systems that don't communicate with each other.
  • Cybersecurity Concerns: Security was largely an afterthought in early implementations. From 2009 to 2023, nearly 5,900 healthcare breaches exposed over 520 million health records, with the average 2024 breach costing $9.97 million.
  • Productivity Drain: Rather than increasing productivity as promised, EHRs have become "productivity vampires" that require extensive documentation and management.

Improvement Needed

EHR systems have transformed patient notes from thoughtful clinical assessments into bloated documentation driven by billing requirements and compliance metrics. Patient notes are now twice as long as they were 10 years ago, yet often contain less meaningful clinical insight. The focus has shifted from holistic patient care to satisfying digital requirements and insurance codes. The IEEE Spectrum article quotes Robert Wachter, Chair of Medicine at UCSF, who states that EHRs "became an enabler of corporate control and outside entity control" over medical practice. Many physicians now practice "checkbox medicine" to satisfy EHR protocols rather than applying the nuanced clinical judgment that characterized previous generations of doctors.

 

Perhaps most concerning is how EHR implementation has contributed to unprecedented levels of physician burnout. Emergency room doctors, who make approximately 4,000 EHR clicks per shift, report the highest burnout levels. This exhaustion inevitably impacts patient care. While old-school physicians like Dr Mugg could focus their energy on clinical reasoning and patient interaction, today's doctors must divide their attention between patients and an increasingly demanding digital ecosystem.

 

Looking Forward

While technological advances including AI scribes (robots) may eventually ease documentation burdens, the fundamental shift away from hands-on medicine represents a significant loss in healthcare delivery. The art of the physical exam—once the cornerstone of medical practice—risks becoming a secondary consideration in our digital healthcare environment.

 

As we continue to digitize healthcare, we must ask whether we've sacrificed something essential in the process: the irreplaceable value of a doctor who looks at the patient rather than the screen.

 

And finally – thanks again Dr Mugg. Enjoy your retirement!